Many of the aircraft he defeated were Fokker DVIIs, the premier German fighter plane of the Great War. It is believed that if he'd been as skilled a marksman as he was a pilot, his tally may well have been much higher and featured near or at the top of the Allied 'ace' list. It was his skills as a pilot rather than his shooting that made him so outstanding. In his whole combat career he was never once wounded.
By the end of World War One Keith had already flown over 1800 hours, and had experience in flying the following aircraft:types:
- Maurice Farman Longhorn
- Maurice Farman Shorthorn
- BE2c
- BE2d
- FE2b
- Avro (undoubtedly the Avro 504K)
- Henri Farman
- Bristol Fighter
- Bristol Scout
- Martinsyde Scout (small)
- Nieuport Scout
- SE5
- SE5a
- Sopwith Camel
- Sopwith Triplane
- Curtiss Seaplane
- Caudron Seaplane
- Fokker D.VII
Between the Wars
Keith remained in the RAF till the 30th of June 1919. On the 17th of July 1919 he then boarded a ship and returned home to New Zealand by ship via Sydney in late August 1919. On arrival in New Zealand he returned home to Cambridge on the 29th of August 1919. After settling back into civilian life Keith began work at his father's manufacturing and importing company of 'Macky Logan Caldwell'.
Sometime around 1920 he had another career change when he took up farming at Glen Murray in north Waikato. He specialised in breeding Angus and Jersey cattle. Despite his farm being an hour or so north of the town he remained firmly in touch with Cambridge, the family home.
On the 14th of June 1923 when the New Zealand Air Force (Territorial) was formed Keith volunteered and was a founding and senior member. with the rank of Major.
Keith was appointed the Commanding Officer of the whole Territorial Air Force Wing in 1930 when it was reorganised, now with the rank of Wing Commander. In February 1936 it was recorded he'd flown 2200 flying hours at that point.
Whilst flying as a territorial pilot with the Air Force, and also being a member of Auckland Aero Club, it turns out that Keith was caught on a technicality in 1933, flying without a licence! The following comes from a letter to Keith from the then Flight Lieutenant Arthur Nevill dated 5th of October 1933:
"Dear Wing Commander,
It has been reported in the October issue of the "Windsok" that you flew cross country from Auckland to Onewhero on September 16th.
As you have no licence, this places both yourself and ourselves in a somewhat invidious position. If you intend to continue civil flying, will you please arrange for a licence to be taken out. If so, please forward fee of 5/- and three photographs of yourself 3 cms. by 2 cms., head to be at least one cm. You will also require to be medically examined by any general practitioner, who should complete the attached form, and return it to this Office."
A rather less bumptious response there than what you might expect from CAA these days if caught flying without a licence!
He continued as Commander of the Territorial Air Force till the 31st of May 1937, at which point he resigned his commission at his own request. At the time when he resigned, the following statement was added to Air Force records by an unknown author:
"Wing Commander Caldwell is now retiring at his own request from the Air Force, and will shortly be posted to the Retired List. His magnificent war record, and the personal qualities which enabled him to lead and organise one of the most famous fighting squadrons on the Western Front, place him amongst the great wartime leaders in aerial combat. His retirement is a heavy loss to the Service, but although he will no longer take an active part in the Territorial Air Force, his presence in New Zealand will remain a fine example to all those who are now undergoing training, and who may one day be faced with the difficulties that he so successfully overcame."
Keith was also president of the veterans group the New Zealand War Birds - a 1930's association of ex-WWI flyers who met annually in Auckland. They first met in 1935 and continued to meet till at least 1938 each year. Cambridge's Tommy Hampshire and Arthur Broadhurst were also members.
Members of the New Zealand Air Force (Territorial), around 1924, from left to
right, unknown, Malcolm 'Mac' McGregor, Len Isitt, Keith Caldwell, unknown
From the Air Force Museum of New Zealand via John Saunders
Members of the New Zealand Air Force (Territorial), around 1924, from left to
right, unknown, Malcolm 'Mac' McGregor, unknown, Keith Caldwell, unknown
From the collection of the late
Malcolm McGregor, via Richard Stowers
World War Two
When the Second World War began Keith was again keen to do his bit. He joined the Royal New Zealand Air Force on the 15th of November 1939, still with the rank of Wing Commander. His first posting on this date was to RNZAF Station Wigram, Christchurch but this was short-lived as he was posted up to RNZAF Station Woodbourne, Blenheim, on the 8th of December 1939.
There at Woodbourne Keith became Officer Commanding No. 2 Flying Training School. Later the school was redesignated as No. 2 Service Flying Training School. As OC of No.2 SFTS he was senior man on the station and thus held the position of the Station Commander for Woodbourne. He held that position of from December 1939 till June 1942, during which time the flying school progressed from flying obsolescent Vickers Vincent biplanes to modern Harvard monoplanes.
While at Woodbourne, Keith was promoted to the rank of Group Captain, on the 1st of April 1942. At this time he and his family were living off station at Maxwell Road, Blenheim.
In June 1942 he transferred south to become the Station Commander of RNZAF Station Wigram, in Christchurch, now becoming Officer Commanding No. 1 SFTS and that famous station's other training establishments until November 1944. Here rather than fighter pilots the station was largely producing multi-engine rated pilots for bomber and transport duties.
Many of New Zealand's finest airmen and WAAF's served and trained at those two stations under his command between 1939 and 1944.
Keith was appointed as an Honorary Aide-de-Camp to His Excellency the Governor General, Air Marshall Sir Cyril Newall on the 26th of March 1943. He was one of twelve military officers appointed to hold this role at any given time. The other RNZAF officers in his first year in the role were Group Captain Sidney Wallingford, Wing Commander John Seabrook and Wing Commander Malcolm Calder. In March 1943 Seabrook and Calder were relinquished of this post and replaced by Acting Air Commodore Maurice Buckley MBE, and Acting Air Commodore Ron Bannerman DFC. Keith held this position through till the 16th of April 1945. This would mean occasional periods working with Air Marshal Newall, whilst retaining his regular role as Station Commander.
Life was not 100% rosey for Keith however, he was suffering from several health issues on and off, including bouts of severe indigestion problems, osteoarthritis and insomnia, and sometimes pain in his right leg. He was however able to continue to fly occasionally - probably just getting about between stations rather than actual training sorties - up till 1944, when doctors finally grounded him.
Keith was an officer who was well liked and respected by all who served under and with him. Like all officers and men of the RNZAF, Keith was the subject of annual confidential reports, where his abilities and progress were assessed by a senior officer. These reports are available in the National Archives and we can see that his superiors rated him highly indeed. Oddly the first three confidential reports covering his service at Woodbourne between December 1939 and June 1942 are in the file but apart from his personal details nothing has been filled in to actually make note of his abilities and ratings, and for two out of three of these reports no-one has even signed them.
However when he moved south to Christchurch these reports became more detailed, and his first report after arriving at Wigram was assessed by Air Commodore George Hodson, RAF, Officer Commanding Southern Group, RNZAF. The period that the first report covered was the 1st of June 1942, when he joined Southern Group, through till the 31st of October 1942. A/C Hodson wrote under 'Special Remarks':
"A strong personality and sound common sense."
And under 'General Remarks' A/C/ Hodson wrote:
"A capable commanding officer. Interests himself in the welfare of his men, and displays considerable interest in the social and sporting activities of his unit. A good leader who maintains discipline, by a fair and just treatment of all ranks."
Air Commodore Sir Robert Clark-Hall became the Officer Commanding Southern Group following Hodson's departure back to Britain, and he wrote the next report which covered Keith's service from the 1st of October 1942 through till the 30th of September 1943. Sir Robert wrote:
"Markedly possesses all the good qualities referred to, the exception that his health is not too good - he suffers from insomnia but never the less is so keen and conscientious that he will only go on leave when directly ordered to do so by me."
Later in the report under 'Remarks (if any) of senior officer', Sir Robert write:
"In my experience as an A.O.C. extending over 10 years (3 Groups, 2 Areas) I have never had a better keener or more efficient station commander in any of my commands."
In January 1944 Keith made a two-week inspection tour of RNZAF Pacific units in the New Hebrides and the Solomon Islands, probably with the Governor General. When he returned to Wigram in early February 1944 he came down with some sort of tropical illness that he'd picked up in his travels, and was forced to spend several days in the Wigram hospital.
In late 1944 another annual confidential report rolled around and was again written by Air Commodore Sir Robert Clark-Hall, covering Keith's working year from 1st of October 1943 till 30th of September 1944. The concluding statement from Sir Robert reads:
"One of the best station commanders which (in an experience of 5 groups or areas) I have ever known. Extreme devotion to duty. In spite of bad health he drives himself to the limit. A born leader. A thoroughly sound organiser. Extremely loyal to his seniors. Takes greatest interest in welfare of his men."
An interesting aside, an extra duty that Keith was asked to perform on many occasions was that of acting as President at Courts Martial and Courts of Inquiry. They included:
Station |
Duty |
Date |
RNZAF Taieri
RNZAF Nelson
RNZAF Nelson
RNZAF Harewood
RNZAF Harewood
RNZAF Nelson
RNZAF Ohakea
RNZAF Harewood
RNZAF Woodbourne
RNZAF Woodbourne
RNZAF Ashburton
RNZAF Harewood
RNZAF Woodbourne
RNZAF Ashburton
|
Court Martial
Court of Inquiry
Court of Inquiry
Court Martial
Court Martial
Court of Inquiry
Court of Inquiry
Court of Inquiry
Court of Inquiry
Court Martial
Court Martial
Court Martial
Court Martial
Court Martial |
20 Dec 1940
02 Apr 1941
12 Sep 1941
01 Oct 1941
03 Oct 1941
30 Dec 1941
26 Jan 1942
25 Jul 1942
23 Mar 1943
07 Sep 1943
18 Sep 1943
12 Oct 1943
07 Jan 1944
18 July 1944
|
Keith was forced to take medical leave for a month or so in October-November 1944 as he was suffering from osteoarthritis in his hips, but he returned to duty in the November. This was a condition he'd been suffering since before rejoining the Air Force in 1939, with sciatic pain down his right leg, but the disability it caused him was intermittent. At that point he was forced to give up flying, not that he did much any more. Regardless of this condition he still regularly played squash and other athletic sports.
Regarding his flying, he'd added a few more Air Force types to his logbook since the First World War list of aircraft earlier in this page. He had also flown the Gloster Grebe, Hawker Tomtit, DH60 Moths, Avro 626 and the Vickers Vincent and Vildebeest between the wars and during the war. He'd also undoubtedly flown many DH60 Moths and numerous other types while flying on the Aero Club scene too.
Regarding that sick leave, he was actually posted from Wigram to No. 3 Sick & Wounded on the 2nd of November, then to No. 1 Sick & Wounded at Remuera, Auckland, on the 14th of November. This was obviously a period of recuperation and rest. It seems for part of this Auckland leave he was staying with hi mother at 16 Arney Road, Remuera.
Then on the 1st of December 1944 he was posted to RNZAF Remuera (Transit), and two days later he embarked (or one document states he emplaned) for India. Now fit again he was posted for overseas duties in India and appointed the role of RNZAF Liaison and Head of the New Zealand Mission to that country. This was officially listed as Special Duties. His actual role was to tour Royal Air Force stations, airfields and depots to meet Royal New Zealand Air Force members serving on units in those places and discuss with these individuals their service and welfare matters. Anywhere he found problems he and his team would endeavour to rectify them, whether it was pay and allowances, recreational matters, personal issues or other such things that arose in the airmen's service lives.
His tour took him to RAF establishments in Eastern India and into the Forward Areas in Burma between the 12th of January and 28th of February 1945. In March 1945 he toured the north and north-eastern stations in India, and in April 1945 he visited bases in Southern India and Ceylon.
Keith was awarded the CBE in the New Years Honours on the 1st of January 1945, and he was promoted to Acting Air Commodore (paid) rank on the 26th of April 1945.
On the 24th of May 1945 he was then posted to England, where he became Air Officer Commanding, RNZAF Headquarters in London, replacing Air Commodore Ted Olson who returned to New Zealand. Much of his duties there involved overseeing the repatriation of New Zealand airmen serving in Britain and Europe back to New Zealand.
At the conclusion of his London posting Keith boarded an aircraft on the 14th of January 1946 to fly home to New Zealand. Upon arrival back in New Zealand from England on the 22nd of January 1946, Keith was posted to the Northern Non-Effective Pool at RNZAF Station Mechanics Bay, which was his last posting before his demobilisation. Air Commodore Keith Caldwell retired from the RNZAF on the 18th of March 1946, and was transferred to the Reserve of Officers. At that time he was 50 years old..
Keith still held his Acting Air Commodore rank at the time of his transfer to the reserve, and Air Force circles discussed this because had he stayed in the RNZAF on return to New Zealand he'd have been reduced back to Group Captain. But it was decided that since he was retiring to the Reserve of Officers and would be unlikely to serve again in the Air Force, they granted him full Air Commodore rank to retire with.
Following his release from the Air Force, Keith continued to farm at Glen Murray. He finally retired and moved to Auckland in 1970 where he lived till his death on the 28th of November 1980, following several years battling cancer. He was survived by his wife Dorothy, and two sons and two daughters. At the time of his death he'd resided at 755 Riddell Road, Glendowie, Auckland.